Sabrina finds herself in trouble when she kisses an old boyfriend, Derek, when he returns and show Sabrina his art work. When she tells Josh, he seems okay. Troubled Sabrina turns to the advice of her roommates, and they assume he's jealous. When Sabrina decides to find out what's wrong with him, a magical whip sends Sabrina and Josh into romantic sagas, and humility ensues. Meanwhile Zelda and Hilda throw a garage sale.
Elenco: Melissa Joan Hart , Beth Broderick , Caroline Rhea , Alimi Ballard , Andrew Walker , Bumper Robinson , China Shavers , David Lascher , Diana-Maria Riva , Elisa Donovan , Jenna Leigh Green , Lindsay Sloane , Martin Mull , Michelle Beaudoin , Nate Richert , Nick Bakay , Soleil Moon Frye , Trevor Lissauer .