The detectives at the 1-2-5 investigate the murder of newspaper journalist Joey Conway. Sam is convinced the killer is the same criminal from a case in 2008. He is motivated by flashbacks to the case, which puts him at odds with his coworkers who think someone else is guilty.
Elenco: Jason O'Mara , Harvey Keitel , Gretchen Mol , Michael Imperioli , Jonathan Murphy , Colm Meaney , Rachelle Lefevre , Lisa Bonet , Greg D'Agostino , Chris Miskiewicz , John Cenatiempo , Odette Annable , Maggie Siff , Heather Matarazzo .