Joan gets a lesson in popularity when God tells her to try out for the cheerleading squad, and her efforts to impress two pom-pom girls pay off with an invite to hang out together outside of school. Meanwhile, Will's first case working with Det. Toni Williams involves an abandoned newborn left in a trash bin, presumably by a student from Arcadia High. Another story line has a classmate sensing a gay vibe in Luke.
Elenco: Amber Tamblyn , Joe Mantegna , Mary Steenburgen , Jason Ritter , Michael Welch , Chris Marquette , Becky Wahlstrom , Aaron Himelstein .