Tabitha goes to pre-school for the first time and meets Amy, a classmate. When the teacher groups the children in animal groups, Amy gets chosen to be a toad in the toad group, but she wants to be in a butterfly group. Tabitha misunderstands her request and actually turns her into a butterfly! Samantha, who has been watching the whole thing through the window, chases Amy the butterfly all around the city and catches her so Tabitha can change her back.
Elenco: Elizabeth Montgomery , David White , Agnes Moorehead , Dick Sargent , Sandra Gould , Bernard Fox , Kasey Rogers , Erin Murphy , Diane Murphy , Ronald Long , Ivor Barry , Alice Pearce .