The first case Georgia brings to Renee's new firm pits them against Cage and Fish. Georgia defends Newman's, an upscale department store against Steve Mallory, who worked as the store's Santa for seventeen years. Cage represents Mallory, who claims that he was wrongfully fired because Newman wants to hire a younger, thinner Santa. Meanwhile, Ally is haunted by visions of herself as a little girl. Ally manages to bring Georgia and Billy together to talk, and Billy sees that he wants Georgia back. But Georgia is not as eager to work things out yet.
Elenco: Calista Flockhart , Greg Germann , Jane Krakowski , Courtney Thorne-Smith , Portia de Rossi , Lucy Liu , Peter MacNicol , Josh Hopkins , James Marsden , Julianne Nicholson , Robert Downey Jr. , Hayden Panettiere .